|
September 22, 2009
Cancelled
The creator of his network’s top-rated
program—Omar Minaya Presents Mets Baseball: See What I’m Saying
walks toward the office door of a studio exec. He pauses for a moment,
adjusts his jacket, and enters.
“Omar, great to see you. Thanks for coming
down. Have a seat. Coffee? Mineral water? You sure you don’t want
anything? No? Okay.”
An audible sigh by the man from behind his
desk.
“Let’s get down to it. The show has gone
in a different direction than we were hoping. The first couple of
seasons, boffo. Getting Pedro…every time he was on camera you could hear
a sizzle. Must-see stuff. That kid with the mole, what’s his
name…Beltran…he looked good, too. The collision in San Diego right at
dinner time gave it a serious tone. Willie with the big Q ratings.
People even liked Victor Diaz and Mike Jacobs! Everyone who went on that
show was great. The Christmas episode with that Benson chick falling out
of her top. Ratings never higher. It was great. Great! Best new show of
the ’05 season. “Goodbye Piazza” in the season finale and “Welcome Back,
Mike” in the middle of the next season. Brilliant.
“I didn’t agree with the ending for year
two—it was like when they killed off McLean Stevenson on M*A*S*H. Big
downer, but people couldn’t wait for the next season to begin. Great
start in ’07. It was knocking off shows that had been hot for years.
Big, big numbers. I didn’t agree with the ending. I still wished I’d
stopped you. You tried to squeeze out too much drama and the whole thing
fell apart. Delgado, Pedro, and that Wagner kid sounded stupid on the
talk shows. Willie looked like he was at a funeral. Not your finest
hour.
“But we had an audience. You brought in
Johan. Biiig star. Willie…that was your call. It was tough, but there
was a lot of buzz about that and Jerry was like Bill Cosby early on.
That laugh, those monologues! But we still had those script problems and
the cliffhanger season finale. Do they always have to end with some kind
of tragedy? Can’t anyone walk away happy? The script almost ignored the
location. You tried to make up at the end, a weepy credit close. Could
have been handled better, but it was what it was.
“This year, big budget, new studio. You
got J.J. what’s his name and um, K-Rod. He was solid. Wasn’t on camera
as much as we expected. You brought Ollie back. It seemed like the right
move at the time. But what happened to the stars of this show? Where was
Johnny Maine? Reyes. He’s supposed to be the star! He was on camera,
what, three times all year. Every episode was about David Wright and it
got stale. Really stale. When you focused too much on him, you lost the
audience. You lost me.
“It’s hard to say this, Omar. But we’re
not renewing the show. It’s cancelled. Sorry.”
“Cancel. You mean Robinson Cancel?”
“No, cancel cancelled…Listen, it’s been a
nice five years. Enough for syndication, so you’ve got that. But See
What I’m Saying has run its course.”
The phone rings. The executive rubs his
hands together, says, “I’ve got to take this.” He picks up the phone and
swivels around to face the window. “Bobby! Long time no speak…” Omar
looks at a framed picture of Reyes dancing, puts his head down, and
walks out the door. Another once-great show cancelled by a network
stooge.
  
I’ve seen worse. Many legitimately great
shows never came to close to lasting as long as See What I’m Saying.
Shows that should have lived long and prospered. Or allowed second
chances (some got reprieves but short leashes). Each of the below shows
were a lot easier to watch than Omar’s work—shows that didn’t have the
maestro of the tragic ending. I watched a lot of TV and like to fancy
myself a minor expert. Indulge me. So now in order of execution, the
metsilverman.com top 10 cancellations that cheesed off this writer the
most…along with the Mets team that best corresponds with the show.
1.
The Twilight Zone (1959-64)
This show lasted five years and there were
a few stinkers in the batch, but no program took ideas and twisted them
as brilliantly as The Twilight Zone. Great performances from the
likes of Burgess Meredith, Jack Klugman, Roddy McDowell, Sebastian
Cabot, Claude Aikens, Telly Savalas. Who loves ya, baby? Apparently not
CBS, which cancelled the show a year before I was born. (The date of
cancellation isn’t as important as its effect on future TV viewing.) I
watched this faithfully as a kid and the annual New Year’s marathon is
still better than 9 out of 10 bowl games. A pity creator Rod Serling
sold the rights that would eventually generate hundreds of millions in
syndication.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Davey Johnson’s 1984 Mets
Just when it seemed that the Mets would be
the perpetually lousy franchise I already had in the then-St. Louis
Cardinals football team, they turned it around at Shea with Doc, Mex,
Darling, Mookie, Rusty, and the whole gang. The Cards also just missed
the NFC playoffs that year. I could have used some Rod Serling narration
after the field goal try sailed right on the season’s last play.
2.
The Famous Adventures of Mister Magoo
(1964-65)
This cartoon was cancelled when I was an
infant, but I watched the re-runs religiously. The adaptation of famous
literature into taut, entertaining, 25-minute episodes is still
unparalleled in my TV experience. Mr. Magoo’s Christmas Carol,
which inspired the show, is still shown annually but the rest of the
episodes are buried. I bought tapes and a bootleg DVD; my kids love the
character created by Jim Backus and the stories he brings to life.
Magoo’s adaptation of Moby Dick would have made Melville proud,
his Cyrano is second only to Jose Ferrer, and his Gunga Din
makes you choked up. Shakespeare in 25 minutes?
Lord, what fools these mortals be.
Cancelled? Damn you, NBC!
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Bobby Valentine’s 1997 Mets
Unappreciated but brilliant. Generation K
doesn’t work? No problem. John Olerud, Rick Reed, and a spit polish
turns a 91-loss team into an 88-win contender. Bravo, Bobby V!
3.
Combat! (1962-67)
Since this show lasted more years than the
U.S. involvement in World War II, this hour-long ABC drama may have run
its course before cancellation…but I would have killed for more
episodes. Re-runs of this came on Saturday morning after The Famous
Adventures of Mr. Magoo. Put that with the great Saturday night
programming of the era, and TV has never had a better day for me. Vic
Morrow was the man on Combat!, along with Lt. Hanley, Caje,
Kirby, Littlejohn, and Doc (who looked like future Mets catcher Charlie
O’Brien). There were G.I. guest stars like Jim Colburn, Lee Marvin,
Mickey Rooney, and even Hall of Famer Warren Spahn (like a lot of the
people in the show, he was a WWII vet). The enemy spoke German without
subtitles, so you had to pay attention to future stars like James Caan,
Ted Knight, Roddy McDowell, and Robert Duvall speaking in tongues and
trying in vain to knock off First Squad.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Davey Johnson’s 1985 Mets
A dynamic squad battles tough foes and
usually finds a way to pull it out (think of Keith Hernandez as Sgt.
Saunders). But there were no guarantees and you had to watch the shifty
enemy platoon led by Herr Leutnant Herzog.
4.
Star Trek (1966-69)
Though never a Trekkie, Star Track
and Star Wreck, as I called it, was a nightly fixture on 11
Alive. The films and other Trek spinoffs became a bit much
(though this year’s film was entertaining). A show that became this
popular only lasting three years? For NBC to cancel it seems…illogical.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Gil Hodges’s 1968 Mets
A ship of souls on the verge of unknown
greatness with a strong guiding hand. You might have to reverse the
roles with Hodges as Spock and Seaver as Kirk, but how about Grote as
Bones, Koosman as Scotty, and maybe Bobby Heise as one of those guys in
the yellow uniform who doesn’t usually make it back from a mission. Set
phasers to stun.
5.
Get Smart (1965-70)
Would you believe it was cancelled by two
networks? NBC gave it the axe in ’69 and then CBS did the same a year
later. Like a couple of others on this list, maybe it was getting stale
at the end, but with a great theme song and excellent writing by Mel
Brooks and Buck Henry, Get Smart was one of the funniest shows
ever. Get Smart was a can’t miss for me: it was re-run on
Saturday morning in between Mr. Magoo and Combat! Saturday
keeps getting better.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Casey Stengel’s 1962 Mets
C’mon, this one’s easy. Great slapstick, a
spy who mangles syntax, and a generally pervading wackiness? Just insert
Marvelous Marv, Richie Ashburn, and Choo Choo Coleman. Fortunately for
America, the Mets weren’t Control, or else Siegfried would rule the
world. “Shtarker, this is Kaos, we don’t ‘Metsie, Metsie, Metsie’ here!”
6.
Kolchak: The Night Stalker (1974-75)
Three previous Night Stalker movies had been
made with Darren McGavin as investigative reporter Carl Kolchak, in his
trademark dingy white suit and straw hit—even during the Chicago winter
he was on the air. Each week he’d find, say, a werewolf on a cruise
ship, or a very large—and dead—Indian, or a monster that took on the
image of your best friend or mom or (in Kolchak’s case) the helpful
hints columnist at Independent News Service. He’d not only track down
the story, but he usually killed the monster as well…and his paper never
ran the stories he risked his life for. That’s journalism! The show
inspired a ripoff play I wrote, produced, and starred in (as the
monster) performed for our fourth-grade class entitled Kodiak: The
Monster Exterminator. Rather than sue me for plagiarism, ABC
cancelled the show.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Yogi Berra’s 1973 Mets
Going up against dangerous Pirate Ghosts
and Big Red Bloody Machines, Tug McGraw is Kolchak (McGraw-McGavin).
Yogi is Simon Oakland—a Twilight Zone vet who was Kolchak’s
editor and shared a name with the city that eventually stuck the stake
in “Ya Gotta Believe.”
7.
The Odd Couple (1970-75)
If I come across The Odd Couple—especially
on Channel 11 after a Mets win—that’s the pinnacle of channel surfing.
After its cancellation by ABC—it’s the first of these shows I watched
regularly while it was still on network—11 Alive grabbed it and ran with
it, putting TOC on five and six times a day at its peak.
Brilliant interplay between the roommates, their recurring ensemble
actors, and guest stars juxtaposed against a deteriorating New York
of the 1970s that was portrayed as a dirty yet vibrant place that still
beat anyplace else. The Odd Couple aired its last episode the
same month Kolchak bought it. Tough year for TV and me. Thanks to
my newfound prime time viewing alternative emanating out of Flushing, it
would be a while before a network show’s cancellation hit me so hard.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Gil Hodges’s 1969 Mets
To me, both the show and the ’69 club are
the unquestionable peaks. That the show came out when the Mets were
still world champions and ended when I was first watching the team makes
it even more of a touchstone between these two rocks.
8.
Tour of Duty (1987-90)
So I’m a sucker for war shows. I was living alone
in rural Massachusetts with only three channels during the last year and
a half of this show’s run. TV had long since given up on Saturday night,
but Tour was the best network show since CBS’s dominance of that
night in the early ’70s. Focusing on an infantry squad in Vietnam, it
was gritty like Combat!, but it had better sets and wasn’t all
shot in the same back lot like my favorite World War II drama. And it
had the opening theme of “Paint It Black” by the Stones and frequently
used songs from Jimi Hendrix, The Band, and Creedence. I was bummed when
CBS cancelled it and I moved on to
China Beach, though that show saw more
action with nurses than soldiers.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Davey Johnson’s 1988 Mets
It was a mismatch on paper and should’ve
been over quickly, but you never underestimate your foe. The favored and
cocky Mets—and their followers—went into L.A. and got ambushed. Mike
Scioscia, Kirk Gibson, and Orel Hershiser undermined Mets strongholds
and morale. Bobby O. was wounded when they needed him on point. Mex got
hurt, too, and couldn’t lead. Coney couldn’t do it alone. A damned
shame.
9.
Homicide: Life on the Streets
(1993-1999)
The only police drama of the group, this
cancellation really burned me up. Every year NBC acted like they were
doing a favor by keeping this superbly-produced, award-winning show on
the air. The cast included Ned Beattie, Richard Belzer, Andre Braugher,
Melissa Leo, Yaphet Kotto, and several lesser-known quality actors.
Based on a book by Baltimore Sun reporter David Simon,
Homicide lasted longer than any show on this list, but its life was
tenuous from its first airing after the Super Bowl XXVII. I never
watched the more sensational NYPD Blue, but I never missed
Homicide. Outrage was so great about the abrupt end to this series
that a film tying up some of the loose ends aired on the network in
2000.
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Bobby Valentine’s 1999 Mets
Clueless commissioner Steve Phillips takes
away captain Bobby V.’s top lieutenants and then orders him to solve
more murders. The drama is intense and the season ends when Kenny
Rogers’s sorry carcass is found in an alley with a Braves hat stuffed in
his mouth.
10.
Freaks and Geeks (1999-2000)
If you don’t remember this show, just look at the
link from the first episode. NBC moved the show around like a Three-Card
Monty game. The mix of undesirables and smart kids coexisting in a 1980
Michigan high school was something I knew about—maybe not the Michigan
part—and the cast was stellar: Seth Rogen, James Franco, Jason Segal,
Linda Cardellini, and SCTV veteran Joe Flaherty. Judd Apatow, who’s gone
on to a few things that did all right, spent most of the budget getting
The Who, Dead, and Billy Joel’s music on the show and even made me enjoy
a Joan Jett song, which I previously thought impossible. I eventually
saw all the episodes the next year when it was aired on the Family
channel. I might have to get that
F&G DVD with features almost as long as
this post. Bite it,
Peacock!
Mets season this show most reminds me of:
Davey Johnson’s 1986 Mets
That club was nearly cancelled in late
October, but those partiers did things their way and—like the show’s
creators and stars—were ultimately successful. NBC tried to play up the
opposition’s angle in the World Series until there was no choice but to
accept the bad guys as heroes. Bite it again, Peacock!
  
The final score: NBC 5, ABC 3, CBS 3 (Get
Smart counts twice)
Davey 4, Bobby
2, Gil 2, Yogi 1, Casey 1
I no longer give my heart so easily to
networks—though I hesitantly trust AMC not to screw up
Mad Men. It will at least see a
fourth season.
As for the Mets…what, like there’s another
channel? |